Here's ads banner inside a post
The British Board of Film Classification (BBFC) is known for its rigorous movie ratings system, but in 2023, two films in particular have sparked an unexpected wave of complaints. The horror film Five Nights At Freddy’s and Billie Eilish’s intimate concert film both made headlines, but not just for their artistic content or box office successes. Instead, these two titles were at the top of the BBFC’s complaints list for the year, raising questions about film ratings and the cultural impact of media on audiences.
A Surprising Pair
At first glance, Five Nights At Freddy’s and Billie Eilish’s concert film seem worlds apart. One is a dark, suspenseful horror film based on the popular video game franchise, while the other is a highly personal, emotional look at the pop star’s world tour. However, both films found themselves at the center of controversy regarding their BBFC ratings, highlighting the growing complexity of film content classification in an age of ever-evolving entertainment consumption.
While Five Nights At Freddy’s has been praised by fans of the game series for its atmospheric tension and jump-scares, it was its violence and dark themes that caused concern among some viewers. The film, which delves into a creepy, animatronic world where children are at risk, sparked complaints from parents and guardians worried about its suitability for younger audiences.
Here's ads banner inside a post
On the flip side, Billie Eilish’s concert film, which captured the highs and lows of her sold-out world tour, was flagged by some for its mature themes, language, and intense imagery. The film’s candid portrayal of the artist’s personal struggles, along with its raw depiction of her concerts, proved challenging for some viewers—especially those who expected a more polished, family-friendly look at the pop star’s career.
A Record Year for Complaints
2023 marked an unusual uptick in complaints about movie ratings, with these two films leading the charge. The BBFC, which assigns age ratings to films based on their content, received hundreds of objections to the Five Nights At Freddy’s film. Many of the complaints focused on the film’s violent imagery and unsettling atmosphere, which some felt went beyond what was appropriate for its PG-13 rating. The BBFC ultimately defended its decision, stating that the film’s fantasy-based horror elements did not warrant a higher rating, but many viewers remained concerned about the level of fear and discomfort it generated among younger audiences.
Here's ads banner inside a post
Billie Eilish’s concert film, which was rated 15, also found itself at the heart of the ratings debate. While the film was lauded for its artistic vision and candid portrayal of Eilish’s life, several parents and guardians voiced concerns over its language, references to mental health, and some of the more intense imagery that accompanied Eilish’s live performances. The BBFC defended the film’s rating, suggesting that the 15 certificate was appropriate given the mature themes explored in the documentary-style film, but the complaints highlighted the growing divide between what certain audiences expect and what the BBFC deems acceptable for specific age groups.
The Changing Nature of Film Consumption
The rise in complaints over these two films reflects a larger trend in how films are consumed in 2023. Audiences today are more discerning and vocal than ever before, especially when it comes to what is deemed appropriate for young viewers. As streaming services continue to blur the lines between cinema and home viewing, film ratings are becoming a hotly debated issue, particularly for content that includes both mature themes and younger audiences.
Films like Five Nights At Freddy’s and Billie Eilish’s concert documentary speak to this generational shift, as they appeal to audiences that straddle the line between adolescence and adulthood. For many, these films offer an escape into fantasy or a moment of raw connection with a beloved artist, but for others, they raise concerns about the impact of such media on young minds. The BBFC is tasked with navigating this delicate balance, striving to protect younger audiences while respecting the artistic integrity of filmmakers.
Are Rating Systems Keeping Up?
The complaints surrounding Five Nights At Freddy’s and Billie Eilish’s concert film raise an important question about whether the current film rating system is still effective in a rapidly changing media landscape. In the past, film ratings were a straightforward way to protect children from inappropriate content, but with the rise of streaming platforms, video games, and immersive multimedia experiences, it’s become increasingly difficult to classify content in a way that satisfies all viewers.
The BBFC’s role is becoming more complex, as movies no longer exist solely in traditional cinema spaces. With films often being available for home viewing almost immediately after their theatrical release, the immediacy of access means that parents must stay vigilant about what their children are watching. This is especially true when films like Five Nights At Freddy’s, which may seem appropriate for certain age groups based on its source material, end up pushing boundaries in unexpected ways.
Billie Eilish’s concert film is another case in point. While fans of the singer may be well-versed in her music and public persona, the intensity of the concert experience in a more intimate, documentary format presents a new challenge for rating systems that weren’t built for such a nuanced view of an artist’s journey. The personal nature of the film—coupled with its mature subject matter—places it in a space that can feel difficult to navigate for both the BBFC and parents trying to make informed choices for their children.
Moving Forward: A Conversation About Content Ratings
The surge in complaints over these films calls for a broader discussion about the future of content ratings and how we define what’s appropriate for audiences of different ages. Are current rating systems equipped to deal with the complexities of modern cinema and streaming content? As movies and documentaries become more immersive and raw, the lines between genres and target audiences continue to blur.
For now, the BBFC stands firm in its decisions regarding Five Nights At Freddy’s and Billie Eilish’s concert film, but the complaints reflect a larger conversation that’s already underway in the entertainment industry. As audiences demand more transparency, and as streaming platforms push the boundaries of content consumption, the future of film ratings is likely to become a point of much greater scrutiny.
