Hollywood’s favorite jokester, Ryan Reynolds, found himself on the receiving end of some unexpected criticism from an unlikely source: Martha Stewart. The 83-year-old lifestyle mogul, known for her mastery of everything from home decor to cooking, recently took a light-hearted jab at Reynolds by claiming he’s “not so funny in real life.” Stewart’s comment quickly circulated across social media, where fans eagerly awaited Reynolds’ reaction. True to form, the Deadpool star replied with a joke—though many noted that the humor seemed slightly more restrained than his usual brand of wit.
Here's ads banner inside a post
The Origins of Martha Stewart’s Comment
The lighthearted feud began when Stewart appeared as a guest on Bilt Rewards’ Rent Free game show. During the interview, she was asked to name celebrities who are considered fun to hang out with. Stewart immediately acknowledged that Ryan Reynolds is likely a popular answer, but she also took the opportunity to share her candid opinion, asserting, “He’s probably on the list just ‘cause he covers himself up in his movies and you don’t see his face.” Stewart added, “You want to know something? He’s not so funny in real life.”
Stewart didn’t hold back as she elaborated, describing Reynolds as “very serious” outside of his acting roles. She did, however, give him credit for his skill on-screen, noting that “he can act funny, but he isn’t funny.” Stewart concluded by playfully suggesting that Reynolds might be able to become funny again, hinting at a potential transformation. Realizing that her comments might stir up some drama, she chuckled and added, “I’m going to get in trouble—he’s my neighbor.” Reynolds and his wife, actress Blake Lively, own a home close to Stewart’s farm in Bedford, New York, making the remark all the more personal.
Here's ads banner inside a post
Ryan Reynolds’ Lighthearted Response
In response to Stewart’s unexpected critique, Reynolds took to social media to share his thoughts. Known for his clever comebacks, Reynolds wrote, “I’d disagree with her. But I tried that once. The woman is unexpectedly spry. She really closed the gap after a mile or so.” Though a bit cryptic, his message seems to joke that Stewart might have chased him down the last time they disagreed, emphasizing her agility despite her age. While many of his fans appreciated the subtle humor, some noted that his reply felt more subdued than his usual comedic style.
The comment from Reynolds did manage to stir up the internet, with fans divided over whether he had “proven her point” by responding in a way that was, as some put it, “not so funny.” Others argued that the humor in his reply lay in its subtlety, fitting well with the lighthearted and neighborly “feud” Stewart seemed to have initiated.
Here's ads banner inside a post
A Neighborly Feud: The Unexpected Relationship Between Reynolds and Stewart
Though it may come as a surprise, Ryan Reynolds and Martha Stewart share more than just celebrity status—they’re neighbors in New York. Reynolds and his wife Blake Lively own a property near Stewart’s farm in Bedford, making her comment all the more intriguing given their proximity. Stewart, who is known for her no-nonsense personality, has occasionally voiced her opinions about other celebrities, but her direct critique of Reynolds’ humor caught fans by surprise.
Stewart’s jab at Reynolds was likely meant in good fun, as she has built a reputation for her sharp wit and candid opinions. The veteran businesswoman and media personality has a habit of speaking her mind, whether she’s offering cooking tips, sharing interior design advice, or giving her perspective on celebrity culture. However, her remark about Reynolds touched a nerve among his fans, who adore him for his comedic charm both on and off-screen.
Stewart’s Picks for “Fun” Celebrities
When listing celebrities she would prefer to spend time with, Stewart mentioned that she would choose George Clooney for his affable personality, describing him as “really nice to hang out with.” She also added Taylor Swift, Brad Pitt, and her longtime friend Snoop Dogg as ideal companions. The hospitality icon left Reynolds off her preferred list, even suggesting she’d “take him off” in favor of someone else, adding fuel to the playful rivalry.
In another playful twist, Stewart admitted that she thought Reynolds might have fans due to his “covered-up” looks in his films, particularly in roles like Deadpool, where he spends much of the film in a mask or heavy makeup. This playful assessment adds another layer to Stewart’s critique, suggesting that his popularity might be more about his mysterious appeal rather than his humor. However, Stewart did acknowledge his talent as an actor, noting that he “can act funny,” but reinforcing her belief that he isn’t naturally funny in person.
Fans React: Mixed Responses to Reynolds’ Comeback
The exchange between Reynolds and Stewart sparked a variety of reactions from fans on social media. While some viewers laughed along with the “feud,” others were taken aback by Stewart’s straightforward critique. Reynolds, widely beloved for his self-deprecating humor and wit, is known for his online antics and playful interactions with both fans and fellow celebrities. To many, Stewart’s assessment seemed off, especially given Reynolds’ reputation for quick humor and comedic timing.
Fans of Reynolds quickly defended him, taking to social media to argue that Stewart might have simply misunderstood his sense of humor. Some supporters suggested that her more traditional, dry style might not align with Reynolds’ modern, quirky approach, which often involves subtle sarcasm and irony. One fan tweeted, “Ryan Reynolds has one of the best senses of humor in Hollywood. Martha just doesn’t get it!” Meanwhile, others took the comment in stride, viewing it as part of Stewart’s characteristically honest approach to life.
A Reminder of Martha Stewart’s Blunt Sense of Humor
Stewart’s remarks are consistent with her long-established public persona. Known for her blunt opinions, Stewart is not one to mince words, whether discussing her own career or sharing her candid views on others. In recent years, Stewart has surprised audiences with her willingness to engage in modern pop culture, most notably in her friendship with rapper Snoop Dogg. Her rapport with Snoop shows her playful side, but her comments about Reynolds suggest she may still lean toward a more old-school sense of humor.
This isn’t the first time Stewart has surprised fans with her remarks about celebrities. In fact, she’s been vocal about her experiences in the public eye, often reflecting on her unique perspective. In a separate interview, Stewart critiqued her recent Netflix documentary, explaining that she “hated” the portrayal of herself as lonely and reflective in later scenes. Stewart noted that she felt the documentary placed undue focus on her 2004 trial and subsequent prison time, which she described as a minor chapter in her life.
Reynolds’ Humor: Not for Everyone?
Ryan Reynolds’ brand of humor has undoubtedly struck a chord with a large audience, but as Stewart’s comment suggests, it may not resonate with everyone. Reynolds often mixes sarcasm with self-deprecation, creating a relatable yet witty persona that has endeared him to millions. Known for his roles in films like Deadpool and Red Notice, Reynolds brings a humorous edge to his characters, adding a playful tone that defines his style.
His frequent social media interactions also contribute to his popularity, as he’s known for publicly joking with his wife, Blake Lively, as well as other celebrities, including Hugh Jackman. For many fans, Reynolds’ humor is precisely what makes him endearing, though Stewart’s assessment hints that some may find it too stylized or “acted” rather than authentic.
A Playful Exchange Between Hollywood Icons
Ultimately, Stewart’s comments and Reynolds’ reaction illustrate the variety in comedic styles and remind fans that humor is subjective. Stewart’s straightforward critique and Reynolds’ “not-so-funny” joke serve as a humorous reminder of the differences in generational humor and the ways celebrities interact. As the internet buzzes with reactions, this lighthearted exchange reveals the personalities behind the fame and reminds fans of the unique nature of Hollywood relationships.
In the end, fans seem to appreciate the exchange, viewing it as a playful moment rather than a serious critique. Whether or not Stewart will consider Reynolds “funny” in the future remains to be seen, but for now, their neighborly banter has added a new, entertaining chapter to Hollywood’s collection of celebrity feuds—albeit one rooted more in amusement than animosity.
