The world of Hollywood is no stranger to legal disputes and public controversies, but the ongoing saga involving actor and director Justin Baldoni, actress Blake Lively, and her husband, Ryan Reynolds, has captured significant attention in the early days of 2025. At the center of this complex and heated legal battle are allegations of harassment, defamation, and professional misconduct, which have now culminated in Baldoni filing a $250 million lawsuit against the New York Times.
Here's ads banner inside a post
This legal action is just one chapter in an increasingly convoluted narrative involving accusations, counterclaims, and conflicting accounts. Here’s a detailed look at the events that led to this high-stakes legal confrontation.
The Catalyst: A Heated Meeting at Reynolds and Lively’s Home
The tensions reportedly began during a meeting at Ryan Reynolds and Blake Lively’s home on January 4, where Justin Baldoni and members of the production team for It Ends With Us were invited to discuss the film’s production. According to Baldoni, the meeting, which was intended to finalize plans for the next day’s shoot, took an unexpected turn. Instead of a productive discussion, Baldoni claims he and his team were “blindsided” by accusations from Reynolds and Lively.
The allegations revolved around what Reynolds described as Baldoni’s “fat-shaming” of Lively. This accusation stemmed from a question Baldoni allegedly asked about Lively’s weight for a scene in which his character was required to lift hers. Baldoni has since defended the inquiry as a safety precaution due to his history of back issues, stating that the question was posed through a trainer recommended by Lively and Reynolds themselves. Despite his explanation, Reynolds reportedly demanded an immediate apology, accusing Baldoni of inappropriate behavior.
Here's ads banner inside a post
The confrontation reportedly occurred as other celebrity guests came and went from the penthouse, which Baldoni described as “humiliating and unprofessional.” When Baldoni refused to apologize, Reynolds allegedly became more agitated, escalating the situation further. The fallout from this meeting marked the beginning of a public and legal dispute that has since spiraled out of control.
Blake Lively’s Harassment Allegations
On December 20, 2024, Blake Lively took the legal battle to a new level by filing a lawsuit against Baldoni. In her filing, Lively accused Baldoni of sexual harassment and orchestrating a “smear campaign” against her after she raised concerns about his behavior on set. She claimed that Baldoni created a hostile work environment and caused her “severe emotional distress.”
Here's ads banner inside a post
The allegations were detailed in an explosive article published by the New York Times on December 21, 2024, titled “We Can Bury Anyone: Inside a Hollywood Smear Machine.” The article, which leaned heavily on Lively’s account, painted a damning picture of Baldoni and his alleged misconduct.
Lively’s lawsuit also described instances where she felt pressured and isolated on set, asserting that her complaints were dismissed or ignored. According to her legal team, Baldoni’s behavior extended beyond professional boundaries, creating a toxic environment during the filming of It Ends With Us.
Baldoni’s Legal Counterattack
In response, Baldoni filed a lawsuit against the New York Times on December 31, 2024, alleging that the publication misrepresented facts, relied on unverified claims, and omitted critical context to frame a false narrative. Baldoni’s legal team, which includes prominent attorney Bryan Freedman, claims the article was deliberately slanted in Lively’s favor and unfairly damaged Baldoni’s reputation.
The lawsuit accuses the New York Times of cherry-picking and editing communications to present a misleading account of events. Baldoni and nine co-plaintiffs, including publicists and other professionals, are seeking $250 million in damages for libel and invasion of privacy. Freedman stated that the lawsuit would “shock everyone who has been manipulated into believing a demonstrably false narrative” and promised to present substantial evidence to support Baldoni’s claims.
Additionally, Baldoni’s legal team is reportedly preparing a countersuit against Lively. This forthcoming action will, according to Freedman, reveal “unprecedented” details and challenge the narrative presented by Lively and her PR team.
The Role of Ryan Reynolds
While Ryan Reynolds has not been named as a defendant in any lawsuits, his role in the controversy has drawn significant scrutiny. As Lively’s husband and a prominent figure in Hollywood, Reynolds’ intervention during the January 4 meeting added fuel to the fire. Supporters of Baldoni argue that Reynolds’ accusations of fat-shaming were exaggerated, while others defend Reynolds for standing by his wife.
Reynolds’ actions have also reignited discussions about the influence of celebrity power dynamics in professional settings. Critics have questioned whether his status may have unduly influenced the trajectory of the dispute.
The Fallout for It Ends With Us
It Ends With Us, based on the bestselling novel by Colleen Hoover, was initially positioned as a major Hollywood release with significant star power. However, the ongoing legal battles have cast a shadow over the project. Production has reportedly been delayed indefinitely, and key scenes, including the contentious lift sequence, have been removed.
Sony, the studio behind the film, has yet to comment on how the legal drama will impact the movie’s release schedule. Industry insiders speculate that the public feud could overshadow the film’s reception, regardless of its eventual release.
Public Reaction and Broader Implications
The case has sparked intense debate among fans, legal experts, and industry observers. Some have rallied behind Baldoni, portraying him as a victim of false accusations and media sensationalism. Others have sided with Lively, commending her for taking a stand against alleged misconduct.
The involvement of the New York Times has further complicated the narrative. As one of the most respected publications in the world, its coverage carries significant weight. Baldoni’s lawsuit raises questions about the media’s responsibility to ensure balanced reporting, particularly in high-profile cases involving conflicting accounts.
What’s Next?
The outcome of these lawsuits will likely have far-reaching consequences for everyone involved. For Baldoni, clearing his name is crucial not only for his career but also for his personal reputation. For Lively, the case represents a battle for justice and workplace accountability. Meanwhile, the New York Times faces its own challenges in defending its journalistic practices and credibility.
As the legal proceedings unfold, the world will be watching to see how this high-profile saga concludes. For now, it serves as a stark reminder of the complexities and controversies that often lie beneath the glamour of Hollywood.
