Steven James, an alum of American Idol, has recently made headlines for his bold critique of Katy Perry’s new single, “OK.” In a viral TikTok video, James shared his unfiltered thoughts on the track, which was released on December 20 as part of the deluxe version of Perry’s latest album, 143. His video has since sparked a wave of reactions from fans, stirring up conversations about the singer’s career, her past decisions as an American Idol judge, and her evolving music style.
Here's ads banner inside a post
The Critique That Caught Everyone’s Attention
In the now-viral TikTok video, Steven James, who was eliminated from American Idol five years ago, reacts to Perry’s new song “OK” with visible distaste. As he listens to the track in his car, James winces at the lyrics and shoots a side-eye at the camera, signaling his disapproval. Over the video, he wrote, “This can’t be the same person who eliminated me on American Idol 5 years ago,” a remark that immediately caught the attention of fans and media alike.
Here's ads banner inside a post
James’ reaction to Perry’s new song is not a one-off instance. It’s a reflection of the complex relationship between American Idol contestants and the judges who hold the power to shape their careers. For James, the sting of being eliminated by Perry all those years ago still seems to linger, and his candid response to her music is an indication of unresolved feelings. The video quickly gained traction, with fans flooding the comments section to share their own opinions on the song, some even comparing it to the theme song of the children’s show Arthur. James humorously responded to this comment with a skull emoji, adding fuel to the fire of his critique.
Katy Perry’s American Idol Legacy
Katy Perry’s tenure as a judge on American Idol has been marked by both praise and controversy. Joining the show in 2018 alongside fellow judges Lionel Richie and Luke Bryan, Perry became one of the most recognizable faces of the competition. Over the years, her interactions with contestants have ranged from warm encouragement to harsh criticism. While many contestants have praised her for her constructive feedback and mentorship, others, like Steven James, have been left with lingering frustrations.
Here's ads banner inside a post
Perry’s decision to eliminate James, a talented contestant, became a pivotal moment in his American Idol journey. For James, it’s clear that the emotional weight of that decision has carried over into his public commentary. His TikTok video, which shows him reacting to Perry’s music, serves as a subtle reminder of the personal toll that American Idol can have on contestants, especially when it comes to facing rejection from high-profile judges.
Despite the bitterness, it’s worth noting that James’ criticism is not solely rooted in personal resentment. His reaction to Perry’s new music also speaks to a broader conversation about the evolution of her sound. As one of the most successful pop stars of the past decade, Perry has undergone significant changes in her musical style, and not all of her fans have embraced these shifts.
The New Song: “OK” and Its Reception
“OK,” which is featured on the deluxe version of 143, has been met with mixed reviews. The song, which was released alongside three other tracks, marks a departure from Perry’s previous hits, showcasing a more experimental and introspective side of her artistry. Some listeners have praised the song for its vulnerability and raw emotion, while others, like James, have been less than impressed.
The reaction from fans has been polarized, with many taking to social media to voice their opinions. Some have expressed confusion over the song’s direction, with one user commenting that it sounded like the theme song from Arthur, the beloved children’s cartoon. Others have criticized Perry for what they perceive as a lack of authenticity in her recent work. Despite the mixed reception, Perry remains steadfast in her belief that the song is a reflection of her personal journey.
In an interview on the Call Her Daddy podcast, Perry explained that her new music is deeply personal and reflects her experiences as a mother and a woman. She described her transformation over the years, speaking about the empowerment she feels from creating life and embracing her role as a matriarch. For Perry, 143 and its accompanying tracks represent a moment of self-reflection and growth.
However, the song’s release has not been without controversy. Earlier this year, Perry faced backlash for collaborating with disgraced producer Dr. Luke on the track “Woman’s World,” which is also part of the 143 album. Dr. Luke, who has been embroiled in a legal battle with singer Kesha, has been a divisive figure in the music industry. Perry addressed the backlash, stating that she worked with many collaborators on the album, and that Dr. Luke’s involvement was just one part of the creative process. Despite the controversy, Perry stood by her work, emphasizing that her music is a reflection of her personal truth.
Perry’s Departure from American Idol
Perry’s departure from American Idol earlier this year marked the end of an era for the long-running competition show. After seven seasons as a judge, Perry made her final appearance during the season 22 finale in May 2024. In an emotional interview with Jimmy Kimmel, she announced that she would be stepping down from the show to focus on other projects, including her music career and family life.
“I think this probably will be my last show, my last season for Idol,” Perry said during the interview. “I mean, I love Idol so much. It’s connected me with, like, the heart of America, but I feel like I need to go out and feel that pulse to my own beat, you know what I’m saying?” Perry explained that while she cherished her time on the show, it was time for her to explore new opportunities and experiences.
Her departure from American Idol has left fans wondering about the future of the show and the dynamics between the judges. While Perry’s exit marks the end of an era, it also opens the door for new talent to step into the spotlight. Whether or not Perry will return to the show remains to be seen, but for now, she seems content with her decision to move on.
The Complicated Relationship Between Contestants and Judges
The dynamic between American Idol contestants and judges is often fraught with tension. For many contestants, the judges represent the pinnacle of success and validation. However, when those same judges make the decision to eliminate a contestant, the emotional impact can be profound. In Steven James’ case, being eliminated by Perry has clearly left a lasting impression, and his recent critique of her music suggests that the hurt from that experience has not fully healed.
At the same time, it’s important to acknowledge that American Idol is a platform that provides countless opportunities for aspiring artists. While rejection is a part of the process, many former contestants, including James, have gone on to find success in their own right. James himself has continued to pursue his music career, and while he may have been eliminated from the show, he remains an active part of the music scene.
For Perry, the relationship with her fellow judges and contestants is undoubtedly complex. As one of the most high-profile figures in the music industry, her role on American Idol has often been scrutinized, and her decisions have been subject to public judgment. Her critics, like James, are not shy about expressing their opinions, but it’s clear that her time on the show has also contributed to her own growth as an artist.
The Lingering Impact of American Idol: A Complicated Legacy for Contestants and Judges
The recent exchange between Steven James and Katy Perry highlights the complicated nature of the American Idol experience and the lasting impact it can have on both contestants and judges. While James’ critique of Perry’s new song may have been fueled by personal feelings, it also serves as a reminder of the emotional weight that comes with the highs and lows of reality television. As both Perry and James continue to evolve in their respective careers, it’s clear that the journey of American Idol is one that stays with its participants long after the cameras stop rolling. Whether it’s through music, social media, or candid moments like these, the impact of the show continues to resonate, proving that for some, the competition is far from over.
