Matty Healy, the frontman of The 1975, has once again stirred up the Taylor Swift fanbase by posting a cryptic Instagram Story on November 17. The post seemingly referenced Taylor’s song “Guilty as Sin?” from her April album, The Tortured Poet’s Department.
Here's ads banner inside a post
The Drama Resurfaces With ‘Downtown Lights’
In his Instagram Story, Matty shared Annie Lennox’s cover of “Downtown Lights” with the caption, “If you don’t know this cover, you are welcome.” Fans immediately connected this to the opening lyrics of Taylor’s “Guilty as Sin?”:
“Drowning in the Blue Nile / He sent me ‘Downtown Lights’ / I hadn’t heard it in a while.”
This post sparked mixed reactions among Swifties. While some found it emotional and nostalgic, others criticized Matty for reigniting drama when Taylor has seemingly moved on.
Here's ads banner inside a post
Matty Healy and Taylor Swift: A Brief Romance
Taylor Swift and Matty Healy had a whirlwind romance in May 2023, shortly after Taylor’s breakup with longtime boyfriend Joe Alwyn. Their relationship gained massive media attention, with Matty attending multiple shows of Taylor’s Eras Tour and being spotted together in New York.
However, the romance ended just a month later in June 2023, leaving fans curious about the reasons behind the breakup. Taylor’s new album, with songs that seemingly reference both Joe and Matty, has only fueled further speculation.
Here's ads banner inside a post
Is ‘Guilty as Sin?’ About Matty?
The song “Guilty as Sin?” quickly became a hot topic, with fans analyzing its lyrics about a conflicted and regretful relationship. Many believe the track is about Matty, especially with the mention of “Downtown Lights” and her “fatal fantasies” about a forbidden connection.
One fan on social media wrote, “If this song is really about Matty Healy, I don’t know how to feel anymore!” Another added, “This drama has been going on for over a decade, and we’re still unraveling it.”
Matty’s Response
Matty didn’t stop at the Instagram Story. On November 18, he posted what appeared to be a tracklist on X (formerly Twitter), sparking speculation about a new album from The 1975. Titles like “Alone Together” and “Owe God a Death” caught fans’ attention.
Some fans believe this is Matty’s way of attracting attention and promoting his new album. One fan commented, “Why do we even care? He’s clearly just trying to get Swifties to talk about him.”
How Has Taylor Responded?
Despite Matty’s antics, Taylor Swift has remained silent. The pop star is focused on her Eras Tour and recently completed a series of shows in Toronto. She has neither confirmed nor denied whether any of her songs are about Matty.
Fans continue to speculate about her relationships with both Matty and Joe Alwyn through tracks like “So Long, London” and “I Can Fix Him.” Most believe Taylor has moved past the drama and is concentrating on her music.
Is This the End or a New Beginning?
The drama between Matty Healy and Taylor Swift is far from over, with every move they make sparking fresh debates. From a brief relationship to being immortalized in songs, their story has captivated fans and critics alike.
Swifties will undoubtedly keep dissecting “Guilty as Sin?” and Matty’s actions. But one thing remains clear: Taylor Swift continues to write her narrative on her own terms.
