Martha Stewart is known for her candor, wit, and sharp insight—qualities that have made her both a beloved and formidable figure in the lifestyle industry. Recently, her playful but pointed comments aimed at neighbor and Hollywood superstar Ryan Reynolds, as well as his wife, Blake Lively, have set social media abuzz. During an appearance on the “Rent Free” game show in November 2024, Stewart described Reynolds, widely recognized as Hollywood’s “funny guy next door,” as being “not so funny in real life.” The remark has since sparked lighthearted banter between Reynolds, Stewart, and even Reynolds’ close friend, Hugh Jackman.
Here's ads banner inside a post
Stewart’s comment has invited attention not only because it pokes at Reynolds’ public image but also due to her longstanding, often supportive, relationship with Blake Lively. Known for her comedic roles and approachable demeanor, Lively once described Stewart as a major inspiration, furthering the intrigue surrounding Stewart’s recent statements.
The “Not So Funny” Comment and Reynolds’ Witty Response
Martha Stewart’s remark came during a segment on “Rent Free,” where she nonchalantly shared her perspective on the Deadpool star’s personality. Speaking candidly, she remarked, “He’s very serious. He’s a good actor. He can act funny, but he isn’t funny.” The comment, perhaps meant as a simple observation, immediately raised eyebrows, given Reynolds’ reputation for his humor both on and off-screen.
For most actors, such a comment might come as an affront. However, Ryan Reynolds, true to form, saw it as a chance for humor. Instead of taking offense, he playfully responded on X (formerly Twitter) with a remark that only added to the amusement: “I’d disagree with her. But I tried that once. The woman is unexpectedly spry. She really closed the gap after a mile or so.” Reynolds’ clever quip diffused any tension and demonstrated his capacity to respond with charm and wit.
Here's ads banner inside a post
Adding to the fun, Reynolds’ friend and fellow actor Hugh Jackman couldn’t resist getting in on the exchange. Known for their playful rivalry, Jackman commended Stewart’s bluntness on X, humorously noting that she was simply saying what everyone had been thinking. The exchange between these three celebrities delighted fans, adding to the growing fascination with Stewart’s honest assessment of Reynolds.
A History with Blake Lively: Supportive but Competitive?
Martha Stewart’s relationship with Blake Lively goes back years, and their dynamic has seen both moments of admiration and subtle competition. Lively has long admired Stewart, once calling her a major inspiration in a 2014 interview with Vogue. The two share a mutual respect and bond, strengthened by Lively’s admiration for Stewart’s career achievements and her knack for entrepreneurship.
Here's ads banner inside a post
However, Lively’s foray into the lifestyle industry in 2014 marked a slight shift in their relationship. That year, Lively launched Preserve, an online lifestyle magazine that she envisioned as a community celebrating curated aesthetics and artisan goods. However, the launch was not without controversy. A feature titled “The Allure of Antebellum” attracted backlash for its association with pre-Civil War themes, which critics argued romanticized an era tied to slavery.
In 2015, Lively made the difficult decision to shut down Preserve, admitting that the site had not fully captured her vision. Stewart, in her usual candid manner, commented on Lively’s venture with what many interpreted as a subtle jab. During an interview with Us Weekly, Stewart remarked, “I’m sorry! I’m sorry! I know she made a big effort. Sometimes shuttering is good. Listen, she’s a movie actress. Why bother with commerce right now? She’s at the top of her career … I’m totally supportive, but you know what? Maybe you can’t do everything at the same time.”
Though her comments seemed well-intentioned, Stewart’s underlying message was clear: the lifestyle industry isn’t easily mastered, and perhaps Lively’s attempt to enter that space was premature. Stewart’s words were tinged with the perspective of a seasoned entrepreneur, revealing the competitive edge she brings to her industry.
“Let Her Try”: Martha Stewart on Blake Lively’s Lifestyle Ambitions
During Preserve’s launch, Stewart had been asked about Lively’s decision to branch into lifestyle and whether she was concerned about competition from the young actress. In a response that balanced support with a hint of skepticism, Stewart stated, “Let her try.” The remark may have seemed dismissive, but Stewart’s point was rooted in the complexity of succeeding in the lifestyle market. While Stewart encouraged Lively to explore her interests, she also hinted at the challenges ahead.
Stewart’s subsequent comments in the same interview highlighted her own love for Hollywood and her curiosity about life on the silver screen. Playfully admitting that she wouldn’t mind swapping roles with Lively, Stewart mused that she might enjoy trying her hand at acting. She was quick to emphasize that she admired both Lively and Reynolds, referring to them as “very friendly, very nice people.”
This seemingly lighthearted exchange between Stewart and Lively reflects a nuanced relationship. While Stewart respects Lively’s creativity, she has remained realistic about the young actress’ challenges in the lifestyle space—a field that Stewart herself has dominated for decades.
The Reynolds-Lively-Stewart Dynamic: Friendship and Playful Jabs
The recent comments about Reynolds’ personality have only added to the intrigue surrounding this trio’s relationship. While Stewart’s remarks were certainly pointed, they seem to carry no ill will. In fact, Reynolds’ humorous response indicates that he takes her words in stride, viewing them as part of their friendly banter.
Similarly, Stewart’s relationship with Lively, though occasionally competitive, is ultimately supportive. Despite her previous comments, Stewart has praised Lively’s talent and expressed admiration for her drive and ambition. Their friendship, albeit complex, has always been defined by a blend of mutual respect and a touch of rivalry.
A Social Media Sensation: Fans Weigh In
As with any celebrity interaction, Stewart’s comments and the ensuing responses from Reynolds and Jackman quickly went viral on social media. Fans of Reynolds relished his witty comeback, applauding his ability to turn a potentially awkward comment into comedy gold. Likewise, Stewart’s remarks were widely shared, with some fans appreciating her unfiltered honesty and others speculating on her motivations.
The playful exchanges drew attention across platforms, with fans taking sides, creating memes, and even calling for a reality show documenting the interactions between Stewart, Reynolds, and Lively. This lighthearted feud, if it can be called that, serves as a reminder of the unique friendships and dynamics that can exist among celebrities.
The Lifestyle and Hollywood Balance: A Rollercoaster Friendship
The relationship between Martha Stewart, Ryan Reynolds, and Blake Lively exemplifies how celebrity friendships can involve admiration, competition, and occasional critique. While Stewart’s shade might seem unexpected, it ultimately reflects her perspective as a successful businesswoman, accustomed to the rigorous demands of building a lifestyle brand.
For Reynolds, this dynamic is simply another opportunity for humor. His response showcases his resilience, willingness to laugh at himself, and talent for diffusing tension with humor. And for Lively, her longstanding friendship with Stewart has perhaps provided valuable lessons about the lifestyle industry—both its appeal and its challenges.
This trio’s interactions capture a snapshot of Hollywood friendships, where witty exchanges and subtle jabs are part of the fun. Whether it’s Reynolds’ playful persona, Stewart’s unapologetic honesty, or Lively’s ambition, the Reynolds-Lively-Stewart dynamic continues to entertain fans and remind us of the fascinating relationships that exist behind the scenes.
As fans await the next playful exchange, it’s clear that these three share a unique bond, defined by a mutual understanding of each other’s strengths and limitations. Stewart’s comments, though occasionally pointed, are ultimately a testament to her respect for Reynolds and Lively as they navigate their own paths in the lifestyle and entertainment worlds. And in true Hollywood fashion, this exchange has left everyone wanting more.
